Pala India, various bodhisattvas (12)

Circa 8th-9th century, Northeastern India, unidentified bodhisattva, copper alloy, 13 cm, private collection, Arts d’Asie lot 64, 12th June 2021, Cornette de Saint-Cyr on aaoarts

According to the catalogue information, this figure seated with a leg pendent holds a fruit or a gem in his right hand and a lotus topped with the head of a makara in the other, which is singular. We will note also the unusual nimbus with seven large blossoms, the backrest with a flower at each corner, the large lotus earrings and matching necklace, the ornate belt, and the garland that goes over both arms and across the lap.

11th-12th century, Northeastern India, Maitreya, copper alloy with silver and copper inlay, 11,4 cm, private collection, Indian, Himalayan and Southeast Asia Art lot 766, 20th March 2024, photo and notes by Sosi Mehren on Bonhams

The future buddha, adorned with a miniature stupa on his head, sits with a leg pendent and his left hand placed over the edge of base to hold a branch, possibly of champaka, topped with an object which Ms Mehren identifies as a ritual water pot. Instead of making the fear-allaying gesture, his right hand is folded towards him.

11th-12th century, Northeastern India, Padmapani (Avalokiteshvara), Tara and Manjushri, stone with cold gold and pigment, 12 cm, private collection, Purity and Enlightenment lot 5, 3rd October 2023, Hollywood Galleries

12th century, Northeastern India, Padmapani (Avalokiteshvara), bronze, 11,5 cm, private collection, as before lot 9.

Pala India, various bodhisattvas (11)

Circa 12th century, Northeastern India, Maitreya, copper alloy, 12,3 cm, private collection, Images of Devotion lot 1854, 1st December 2023, Bonhams (Hong Kong).

The future buddha is identified by the stupa on the flower he holds in his left hand. The right hand is raised to dispel fear.

Pala period, Northeastern India, Avalokiteshvara, (copper alloy with silver-inlaid eyes), photo by Sunil Dongol, Dharmadeva Caitya, Chabahil (Kathmandu, Nepal).

Seated with a leg pendent, the bodhisattva of infinite compassion holds the stem of lotuses in his left hand and makes the boon-granting gesture with the other.

10th-11th century, Northeastern India, ‘bodhisattva, probably Avalokiteshvara’, stone, 37,4 cm, accession nº SC 1963.81 at the Smith College Museum of Art in Massachussetts (USA).

A princely figure making the fear-allaying gesture with his right hand and holding a rosary in the other. There seems to be a stupa between his chignon and his low tiara, that would identify him as Maitreya.

11th-12th century, Northeastern India, Mahakaruna Lokeshvara, gilt bronze, 12 cm, Art d’Asie lot 360, 7th June 2011, Christie’s (Paris).

This form of Avalokiteshvara normally has an effigy of Amitabha in his hair and his right hand over his knee. In this case the hand is resting on the meditation strap fastened around his raised knee.

Circa 12th century, Northeastern India, Shadakshari Lokeshvara tsatsa, polychrome terracotta, 8,8 cm, The Triay Collection of Himalayan Art lot 402, Bonhams (Paris).

Avalokiteshvara with four hands, the main ones joined before his heart to enclose a wish-granting gem, the other two holding a rosary (not visible here) and a lotus.

Pala India, Manjushri – seated (6)

Circa 11th century, Northeastern India, Manjushri, brass with silver and copper inlay, private collection, Images of Devotion lot 1853, 1st December 2023, Bonhams (Hong Kong).

Seated in the royal ease position, the bodhisattva of wisdom is flanked by blue water lilies – one of them supporting the Prajnaparamita sutra. His knee-length dhoti is decorated with a stippled floral pattern and a row of silver and copper roundels typical of the place and period. The sash tightly drawn across his chest, the stem of the flowers, and his armbands also have a stippled decoration.

11th-12th century, Northeastern India, Manjushri, stone, 46,4 cm, private collection, Arts of India lot 574, 27th September 2023, Christie’s

There are two forms of Manjushri seated on a snow lion, in the vajra position or with a leg pendent, and making the ‘turning the wheel of dharma‘ gesture. Simhanada Manjughosa may have a flower to his left but no book on it. He usually has an effigy of Akshobhya in his crown. Vadisimha holds the stem of a blue water lily wound around his left arm with the flower level with his shoulder and topped with the Prajnaparamita sutra.

Pala India, Avalokiteshvara – seated (7)

8th-9th century, (North)eastern India, Avalokiteshvara, stone, 47 cm, private collection, Auction A136AS lot 233, 25th March 2006, Koller

Avalokiteshvara, identified by the effigy of Amitabha in his hair and the open lotus in his left hand, is seated with a leg pendent atop a lotus throne with a tiny kneeling figure below who is offering a garland. His right hand displays the gesture of supreme generosity.

11th century, North(east)ern India, Avalokiteshvara, metal, item 7540 on HAR, at the Nalanda Museum (India).

Also with an effigy of Amitabha in his hair and the stem of an open lotus in his left hand, the bodhisattva of compassion makes the fear-allaying gesture with his right hand. He is seated with his legs locked, atop a throne supported by lions, and flanked by elephants, makaras, and hamsas.

11th-12th century, Northeastern India, Padmapani (Avalokiteshvara), bronze, 7 cm, private collection, Arts of India lot 571, 27th September 2023, Christie’s

Pala India, various bodhisattvas (10)

10th century, Northeastern India, Vajrapani ? (labelled ‘Akashagarbha’), iron or bronze, 8,3 cm, The Moke Mokotoff Collection, lot 307, 13th September 2023, Christie’s

This figure holds an upright vajra sceptre in his right hand and a bell in the other, pressed against his hip – an iconography which corresponds to buddha Vajrasattva. Vajrapani usually clutches the vajra sceptre rather than hold it upright in the palm of his hand; however, we have seen a few Pala Period sculptures of him holding it upright. (The sculpture is labelled ‘Vajrapani’ on HAR  )

11th-12th century, Indian work for Tibetans, Tikshna Manjushri, stone, photo: courtesy of Ulrich von Schroeder, Buddhist Sculptures in Tibet Volume One, Visual Dharma Publications, Hong Kong, p. 379 pl. 120C Potala Collection, Phags pa lha khang inventory nº 92, Lhasa (Tibet)

This aspect of the bodhisattva of wisdom has one head and two or four arms. The four-arm form wields a sword in the upper right hand and holds an arrow in the lower; one of the left hands clutches a bow and the other holds a manuscript at heart level, or the stem of a blue water lily that supports the manuscript (as above).

Circa 12th century, Northeastern India or Tibet, Shadakshari Lokeshvara, stone, 9,6 cm, photo as before (p. 378 pl. 120A), Potala Collection, Lima Lhakhang inventory nº 1539, Lhasa (Tibet).

Shadakshari Lokeshvara always sits with his main hands holding a wish-granting jewel before his heart, the upper right one clutching a rosary (and in this case an additional flower), the left one holding a white lotus. This form of Avalokiteshvara is the embodiment of the six-syllable mantra ‘om mani padme um’.

Pala India, Avalokiteshvara – various forms (2)

10th century, Northeastern India, Padmapani (Avalokiteshvara), stone, 13,8 cm, private collection, Arts d’Asie lot 142, 15th June 2023, Sotheby’s (Paris).

The bodhisattva of compassion, identified by the effigy of Amitabha in his hair and the lotus in his left hand, flanked by two female attendants.

10th century, Northeastern India, Padmapani Lokeshvara, stone, size not given, Indian, Himalayan and Southeast Asian Works of Art lot 757, 16th March 2016, Sotheby’s

A similar depiction in quite a different style, with the right hand intact and a lotus flower in its palm. He is attended by two yaksha figures, one of them possibly Yellow Jambhala holding a mongoose in his left hand and a fruit in the other.

Circa 11th century, Northeastern India, Avalokiteshvara, silver alloy, 55,3 cm, photo: courtesy of Ulrich von Schroeder, Buddhist Sculptures in Tibet Volume One, Visual Dharma Publications, Hong Kong, p. 311 pl. 106 B, at the Ngor E wam monastery, Tsang province (Tibet).

Apart from the locks of hair piled into a tall chignon (jatamukuta), this looks like the padmapani form too, but the monks told the author that the statue represents the khasarpana form of Avalokiteshvara.

There is an effigy of Amitabha between his hair and his tiara. His left hand makes the gesture to bestow refuge (tip of the ring finger against tip of the thumb).

11th-12th century, Indian work for Tibetans, Sadaksari Lokesvara attended by Manidhara and Sadaksari Mahavidya, stone, 13,8 cm, photo as before (p. 383 pl. 122 B), Potala Collection, Lima Lhakhang inventory nº 1576, Lhasa (Tibet).

The most common four-arm form of the deity always sits with his main hands joined before his heart to hold a wish-granting gem; his other right hand clutches a rosary, the left one holds a lotus. His attendants are Manidhara (male), who may have two or four arms, and Shadakshari Mahavidya, who is Shadakshari Lokeshvara’s female equivalent. In this case, Manidhara has two hands, in which he holds a jewel and a flower topped with a jewel. According to the author, the two figures above the attendants are monks: an Indian teacher and his Tibetan disciple (yet the latter wears a layman’s garment with long sleeves). There is an effigy of Amitabha at the top of the arch.

11th-12th century, Indian work for Tibetans, Amogapasa with Tara, Sudhanakumara, Hayagriva, and Bhrkuti, stone, 11,5 cm, photo as before (p. 381 pl. 121 C), Potala Collection, Lima Lhakhang inventory nº 1633, Lhasa (Tibet).

Amoghapasha, whose name means ‘unfailing lasso’, is usually understood as a form of Avalokiteshvara, yet he has a very different iconography. He may have two arms, in which case he holds a ring in his left hand, or four, six, eight, or twelve arms (Alice Getty even mentions one with 20 arms), in which case one of his attributes is always a noose or a lasso. The eight-arm form always holds a tridandi (a trident made of three lotus stalks) in one of his left hands, and usually has the stalk of a lotus, a manuscript, a water pot in the remaining left hands, as above. Two of the right hands hold a rosary and a noose respectively, the third one makes the fear-allaying gesture and the lower one makes the gesture of supreme generosity.

Pala India, Manjushri – standing (2)

11th century, Northeastern India, Manjushri, gilt copper, 48,5 cm, photo: courtesy of Ulrich von Schroeder, Buddhist Sculptures in Tibet Volume One, Visual Dharma Publications, Hong Kong, p. 318 pl. 110A, Potala Collection, Lima Lhakhang inventory nº 1324, Lhasa (Tibet).

Brandishing a sword in his right hand and holding the Prajnaparamita sutra against his heart in the other,  Manjushri stands on a small lotus base atop a multi-tier stepped and legged pedestal (meant to be a yantra) that is probably not the original: as observed by the author, the image is too small for the lotus-shaped nimbus (which is far to high above his head) and the pedestal. The flaming mandorla is topped with a (damaged) finial quite different from the usual parasol, and there are a couple of geese on the crossbar.

11th-12th century, Northeastern India, Manjughosa, brass, 20,4 cm, photo as before (p. 277 pl. 90C), Potala Collection, Bla ma lha khang, inventory nº 399, Lhasa (Tibet).

A rare image of Manjushri standing with his hands making the ‘turning the wheel of dharma‘ gesture and flanked by flowers supporting a manuscript on each side (rather than the hilt of a sword to his right).

12th century, Northeastern India, Bengal, Manjushri, copper alloy, photo on Pratapaditya Pal , inventory nº M.75.4.10 at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (USA) (nowhere to be found on their website).

Pala India, Vajrapani (5)

11th century, Northeastern India, Standing Vajrapani, silver alloy painted with cold gold, 59 cm, photo: courtesy of Ulrich von Schroeder, Buddhist Sculptures in Tibet Volume One, Visual Dharma Publications, Hong Kong, p. 311 pl. 106D, at the gTsug Lhakhang of the Ngor E wam monastery (Tibet).

As we saw in the Tibetan section of this blog, early portable sculptures depicting the bodhisattva Vajrapani standing don’t always include a vajra bell on the flower he holds in his left hand. In this case, the right hand would have held an upright vajra sceptre now lost.

Pala India, Avalokiteshvara – seated (6)

11th-12th century, Northeastern India, Avalokiteshvara, Khasarpana, attended by Sudhanakumara and Hayagriva, brass with cold gold, pigment, 12,6 cm, photo: courtesy of Ulrich von Schroeder (Buddhist Sculptures in Tibet, Volume One, Visual Dharma Publications, Hong Kong, p. 271, pl. 87B), Potala Collection, inventory nº 665 at the Lima Lhakhang in Lhasa (Tibet).

We saw another such triad from the Potala collection, with Avalokiteshvara seated with the right leg pendent and holding a lotus in his left hand. Sudhanakumara, to his right, is identified by the book tucked in the crook of his left arm. Hayagriva, on the other side, is identified by the gesture he makes toward the main deity when appearing as an attendant (vandana mudra). He normally leans on a danda stick but in this case the object curls up like a snake.

11th-12th century, Northeastern India, Avalokiteshvara, brass with silver and copper inlay, 10,4 cm, photo as before (p. 292, pl. 97A), Potala Collection, inventory nº 1681 at the Bla ma lha khang, Lhasa (Tibet).

A rare image of Avalokiteshvara in his eleven-head form, seated, with only four arms and an unusual head arrangement (4+4+2+Amitabha’s). His lower right hand makes the gesture of supreme generosity, the upper one holds a rosary, his upper left hand holds a lotus, the lower one clutches a water pot.

12th century, Northeastern India, Avalokiteshvara with Suchimukha, brass, turquoise and glass, 25 cm, photo as above (p. 239, 72B), Potala Collection, inventory nº 359 at the Lima Lhakhang, Lhasa (Tibet).

Suchimukha, a hungry ghost (preta) with a pointed mouth designed to drink nectar from the hand of Avalokiteshara, is kneeling at the front of the elaborated mandala-shaped stepped plinth. (See more about hungry ghosts on Dharmasun ).

Pala India, Avalokiteshvara – standing (3)

Circa 10th century, Northeastern India, Bihar, Avalokiteshvara, basalt, photo by Biswarup Ganguly on wikimedia, accession nº 5861 at the Indian Museum in Kolkata (India).

A rare image of Avalokiteshvara in his padmapani form, with a large effigy of Amitabha in his headdress, another buddha on the lotus he holds in his left hand, and a third on the halo, which is supported by makaras. He is flanked by two attendants seated in a relaxed manner on separate lotuses, and leogryphs (viyalas) above them. His right hand makes the gesture of supreme generosity.

Pala period, Northeastern India, Avalokiteshvara, copper alloy, 14,2 cm, photo by Sunil Dongol, 2010, courtesy of Ulrich von Schroeder, Dharmadeva Caitya, Chabahil, Kathmandu (Nepal).

Pala period, Northeastern India, Avalokitesvhara, copper alloy, same as before.

On this metal work, complete with its flaming arch and legged base, the needle-nosed ghost Suscimukha/Suchimukha appears on the pedestal, ready to drink the nectar that drops from Avalokiteshvara’s hand.

Pala period, Northeastern India, Avalokitesvhara, copper alloy with silver-inlaid eyes, 11,1 cm, same as before.

Avalokiteshvara in one of his four-arm forms; the extra pair of hands hold what may be a fly whisk and a water pot (?).